(SoR isn’t a pendulum swing, SoRm is.)
[Published July 31 2026 on Substack]
I first became interested in literacy when I ‘accidentally’ did OG training, because my wife had signed up for it, but double booked. So I put my hand up. My step-daughters were struggling, and all roads (having exhausted other options) led to home tutoring.
Based on what I’d learnt about the state of literacy instruction in my home state of Tasmania and internationally, I petitioned government, wrote a background paper (Merchants of Illiteracy)for that petition, and caused a bit of a stir by flagging a class action against our education department. Our public broadcaster ran a video nationally on TV and web about our story and, soon after, “angry farmer literacy” was listed by Google as a trending search.
In that ABC interview, I paraphrased Snow & Juel’s “helpful for all children, harmful for none, and crucial for some“ pronouncement, and I began my background paper noting that the type of instruction that dyslexics need, is helpful for all children.
It’s been a while since I read that paper, but I think I’d still stand by what’s in it. Even back then, I was noting the tension between the need for explicit instruction, and the capacity humans have for implicit statistical learning. It’s the level of granularity and amount of explicit instruction that varies between dyslexics and non-dyslexics, I wrote.
My petition called for the canning of contracts made with ‘balanced literacy’ consultants, and seeking advice from the Australian Education Research Organisation (AERO) instead. As part of a wider (and already in-motion) literacy instruction reform (Tasmania’s ‘Lifting Literacy’), those contracts were indeed cancelled, a freeze was placed on new engagements, one of the most comprehensive and aspirational sets of recommendations was made and adopted, and AERO was given a seat at the table.
It looked like we were on the cusp of intergenerational change.
In amongst all that, I was approached to join Code REaD Dyslexia Network, a national charity advocating for those with SLDs and for quality instruction, and over the last three years, I’ve watched as Tasmania’s education juggernaut has indeed been turned around, in respect to literacy instruction.
But the amount and granularity of explicit instruction is what differs between dyslexics and non-dyslexics. And there seems to have been no recognition of that in the current implementation. Putting it another way, our education system is still a juggernaut, and while it’s at least headed in the right direction, I fear it’s already gone too far.
The sense of the problem that sits with me as I think about it, is a flywheel. The implementation had a flywheel attached from the outset, storing energy to ensure that it had enough to make the sweeping changes that were required. Energy to overcome ingrained cultural resistance, and to de-implement established Eduwoowoo. And it’s worked, but that flywheel has also resulted in the juggernaut being pushed along when a pause would’ve been beneficial. When some nuance was required.
And now I’m a bit scared.
We’ve been here before.
The following warning came from Keith Stanovich, writing over 30 years ago, in a guest article, “Romance and Reality”, predicting that if whole language proponents continued to ignore the evidence around the importance of phonics, they’d be swept away:
“The danger is this. In holding to an irrationally extreme view on the role of phonics in reading education… …whole language proponents threaten all of their legitimate accomplishments. Eventually – perhaps not for a great while, but eventually – the weight of empirical evidence will fall on their heads.”
One could certainly argue that this was quite a prescient observation, given the effective blackballing of whole language that has occurred in recent years, which has been manifest in policy settings and even legislation in many jurisdictions internationally.
Many educators, researchers and advocates were relieved to see those “irrationally extreme views” put in their place (and many – including me – contributed to that effort), and are forging forward in the space that’s created.
But, given we’ve just been privy to that turning of the tide, we should also be especially cognisant of the fact that it can turn again. Let me suggest (outrageously?) an equivalence:
The danger is this. In holding to an irrationally extreme implementation privileging the role of phonics in reading education… …structured literacy proponents threaten all of their legitimate accomplishments. Eventually – perhaps not for a great while, but eventually – the weight of empirical evidence will fall on their heads.
Is it possible? Let’s consider that possibility. Because, if it is possible, the folks who are currently apologists (for the very best of reasons) for over-teaching, may not be protecting us all from a return to the next iteration of balanced literacy, but rather speeding that return by pushing the pendulum higher.
I should note that I’m mostly talking specifically about what I’m hearing about the Tasmanian literacy landscape. How well this applies to other contexts, I’ll leave for others in those contexts to decide, though there are certainly indications that it reflects the general zeitgeist.
SoR(m)
The Science of Reading movement (as opposed to the science of reading) is on pretty shaky ground. When you have folks like Mark Seidenberg – who has gone to incredible lengths to promote the adoption of reading research in education – is making statements like the following, it has to be a pretty big red flag for anyone who’s paying attention:
“We’re kind of mired in this version of the science of reading that somebody invented, and it’s not very much science at all.”
“There’s so much teaching going on of so many things that were never taught before. It’s time consuming. It’s now starting earlier in pre-K and ending later, people are still teaching phonics and word structure in grades 3 and 4. This is making it complicated and it’s not even known whether it’s effective.”
“…if you’ve got a curriculum that’s like a plodding approach to learning to read, it goes in tiny little bits and steps and really keeps the kid away from reading for a long time – that to me is where we need some changes.”
“The problem with those materials is they’re excessive, and they don’t have off-ramps. There’s no way for the kid who’s making progress and could go off and read, to go off and read. We’ve got to stick with it and go through the 128 lessons.”
“There’s a lot of time and wasted effort, there’s some overteaching going on, and it’s taking away from reading activities…”
It’s not just neuroscientists, either (because, pfffft, if it was, we could just ignore them…) A parent who has advocated for structured literacy recently told me that their child – who arrived at school already reading – had completely disengaged from reading as a result of having to sit through UFLI lessons. “‘Harmful to none’ means physically harmful, right?”, she suggested, trying to reconcile the research quote to the reality she’d watched unfold.
A teacher (who has changed schools multiple times looking for somewhere that would support explicit instruction, well before the Lifting Literacy mandate was in place) confided that they’d witnessed “death by literacy” in action during a UFLI lesson – too slow for some, not enough granular practice for others.
A recent study brief – which may be overly enamoured with the Active View of Reading, but I’ll take this finding at face value – rounded up an examination of K-2 instruction (using Amplify CKLA, UFLI, or Wilson Fundations) noting that:
Study findings show that teachers in these districts were consistently using the foundational skills curriculum; their lesson purposes supported foundational skills instruction; and they were providing clear, explicit instruction—all necessary components of strong foundational skills instruction. However, the lessons rarely included substantial opportunities to build reading fluency or vocabulary development; in only one-fifth of lessons did students have the opportunity to apply their foundational skills knowledge beyond single words to phrases, sentences, or paragraphs, and in over half of observed lessons, word meaning was addressed once or not at all.
Stanovich, in the article quoted above, noted that ‘too much phonics’ isn’t a new complaint, even amongst those who advocated for its fundamental importance:
Chall (1989) has no compunctions about admitting that “Some teachers may inadvertently overdo the teaching of phonics, leaving little time for the reading of stories and other connected texts”…
…It seems inconceivable that we will continue wasting energy on the reading wars simply because we cannot get both sides to say, simultaneously, “some teachers overdo phonics” and “some children need explicit instruction in alphabetic coding”.
My concern is that we’re now in a place where it’s not quite so personal… it’s not particular teachers anymore, but rather that (even more heretically?) “some sectors/districts/states overdo phonics”.
Let’s look at Tasmania.
Literacy Lifted
As I understand it (corrections welcomed), we now have our education department recommending (or mandating, depending on whom you ask):
- Heggerty for phonemic awareness. Around 10 minutes daily (too much for most kids) of mostly oral-only tasks (not required by most kids, and therefore less effective), in a scope and sequence that, thanks to graphic design, looks like very organised scattergun output.
- UFLI Foundations for phonics. For three years. Including two weeks of introductory lessons that include instruction on linguistic vocabulary such as “fricative”. Intervention placement is by reading, which means spelling will not be addressed at the level it needs to be (I have seen kids who meet or exceed DIBELS ORF benchmarks who spell at =/<1st percentile – even below the first percentile of spelling, they would not be flagged by the UFLI intervention placement).
- Word Origins for morphology – a program that explicitly states it’s to be used after completion of a phonics program (and it certainly would need to be for weaker readers, because it assumes code-knowledge and jumps around week-to-week between morphemes featuring the ‘basic’ to ‘complex’ codes… duct, kilo, cede, script, form, cycle, sign, flect). So, starting year 3 here in Tasmania, after UFLI is done. I’ve only seen ‘Level 1’, which covers around 50 morphemes in a school year (I assume levels 2 and 3 will take a child to the end of year 5). Children who are already readers when they arrive at school would benefit from exploring morphology instruction, but will they get that opportunity? Children who don’t arrive at school already reading, can also benefit enormously from morphology instruction that features morphemes adhering to a phonics scope and sequence – but UFLI and Word Origins are not compatible for simultaneous use, unless teachers slice and dice like infidels. Yet another cohort – kids who don’t arrive as readers but who will nevertheless acquire reading very easily – could benefit from Word Origins far earlier in their instruction, wherein ‘cycle’ could well be taken in stride.
- Corrective Reading (not spelling) for tier 2 & 3 intervention. This comes from the SRA/Engelmann stable, a scripted ‘solution’. Engelmann was a giant, but the closer you get to the tier 3/4 end of the wedge, the less useful a script becomes. Or, as one of my employers retorts, “What are you going to do when the script doesn’t work?” Because it most likely won’t. Because one kid’s problem will be that she’s getting interference effects between writing dge and igh, and another can’t hear the difference between dge and tch, and another needs to decode a CVC word 100 times before he recognises it. Tier 3 is where you need the most skilful, knowledgeable teaching. Thankfully, to get there, we have…
- Qualiteach. For deeply flawed online teacher training.
This silo approach to literacy is the antithesis of efficiency (and doesn’t reflect the intertwined nature of the orthography), in the name of… efficiency? Quality?
Phonemic awareness doesn’t need to be separate to phonics, for the overwhelming majority of kids. Why have two separate programs, each with its own demands to fidelity?
Morphology doesn’t need to be separate to phonics, for the overwhelming majority of kids. Knowledge sticks to knowledge, on the condition that the new knowledge isn’t multiple ‘steps’ away from the established knowledge. That’s why sequential, cumulative learning works. But it can be sequential and cumulative between the silos (or between the strands of Scarborough’s reading rope, if you prefer): the single grapheme ‘s’ is also a morpheme. You can’t actually not teach morphology with the ‘basic code’ unless you avoid all plurals. So why not just embrace morphology rather than only teaching it if it’s unavoidable? Especially since Brian Byrne made a good case that kids assume our orthography primarily consists of semantic representations. A child who can blend, with a solid enough working memory, who knows basic GPCs, can decode ‘distracts’ with some guidance. So why wait until grade 3 to teach it?
UFLI is less ‘scripty’ than Corrective Reading, but Corrective Reading is going to be used in the space where scripts are less likely to be successful. I’m yet to see Corrective Reading, but I’m quite confident that its (likely tacit) scope and sequence won’t align with UFLI’s, which will result in kids feeling like they’ve stepped out of one program into another – which they will have – rather than simply getting more granular support.
I’ve written before that we will likely see implementation casualties, and at that point I was referring to the tier 3 end. I’m now worried that we’re setting tier 1 one up to experience exactly the problem that Misty Adoniou argued has been our problem all along – a lack of ‘complexity and joy’. I pointedly critiqued this argument as spurious in my Merchants of Illiteracy paper, because she’d deliberately compared apples to oranges while making it. But if we are actually now pushing all kids through 6 years of explicit instruction in the kinds of information most kids will master implicitly, where will they have the opportunity to actually engage in that far broader, far more effective, implicit statistical learning? Will they be so far behind in their exposure to actual texts, that their vocabularies haven’t developed accordingly? Will they have ever been exposed to a genuinely complex sentence, as opposed to a Complex Sentence?
Can kids who would actually have thrived under balanced literacy, possibly reach the same levels of comprehension after 6 years of basic skills training? The question sounds absurd… I mean, it’s not like anyone’s actually stopping them from reading uncontrolled texts, is it? Is it? Absurd… until you remember the kid who has lost all interest in reading due to UFLI. Or will the data in 5 or 10 years time bury those cases as just outliers? It’s a huge gamble, “and it’s not even known whether it’s effective.“
Put is this way: are we creating the conditions where we make Misty Adoniou correct?
Personally speaking…
I noted in the intro to Merchants of Illiteracy that I’ve been a parent to kids at both ends of the literacy spectrum. My eldest daughter won ‘all the things’. My youngest was diagnosed dyslexic mid-Primary. I’m not confident that Lifting Literacy would have worked for either of them. And I’m quite confident that they’d both hate it after 6 years of it.
I know why raising these concerns is seen as ‘dangerous’ in structured literacy circles. I’ve had the insults and the slights and eye-rolling from balanced literacy stalwarts. I was even approached by a balanced literacy academic after I introduced Distinguished Professor Pamela Snow at a university social justice lecture last year and, as far as I could tell, the approach was simply to intimidate me (which, in hindsight, was quite humorous, because at the time I couldn’t even remember who she was). I know the old guard is still waiting in the wings to make a comeback.
What I’m saying is… are we actually making it easier for them? Are we going to have a generation of kids that includes a swag who can read – just – but don’t, because they hate it, along with the kids who still can’t read because we opted for programs rather than teacher training?
I hope I’m wrong to be concerned. But, in case I’m not…
Let’s talk about Escape Velocity
Where are the off-ramps from phonics within structured literacy? Or, perhaps, it’s an implementation problem rather than being inherent in structured literacy?
Mark Seidenberg’s notion of escape velocity is a useful concept to communicate these concerns: escape velocity is where the kid has learnt enough to be able to self-teach through exposure to text. I’m yet to see it expounded as something practically useful (though I did see him suggest somewhere that screeners that demonstrate learning beyond what’s been taught, would be a useful probe for someone to develop).
UFLI has been in place in Tasmania for some time now. Teachers must already be aware of the kids who are way ahead of what they’re teaching. Let’s talk about that… what are the signs? What indicates that a child is ready to be let loose into literacy?
I’ll start… (again, only from a tier 3 perspective, not a classroom).
There’s a benefit in having some decodables that are not strictly aligned to your scope and sequence. There may only be a grapheme or three on a page that you’ve not taught. You can gauge how the child tackles that. Is it completely inscrutable to them? Does language strength and set for variability allow them to tackle it? Was it barely challenging? In this way, you can move from controlled to uncontrolled texts with some confidence. I imagine (pure conjecture) you could achieve something similar in classrooms with choral/paired reading… let the kids who know more of the code ‘teach’ those who know less, but within the confines of only a few unknown graphemes. I’ve seen kids take off within weeks once they are able move into ‘less controlled’ texts, and unless a child is quite profoundly dyslexic, I tend to err on the side of ‘slightly uncontrolled texts’ rather than ‘tightly controlled texts’ – depending on the child’s confidence.
I’ve also noticed a point at which flashcards start to ‘get in the way’. There’s a point at which “au” in isolation becomes less ‘readable’ than “pause” in isolation. They can read it in a word more easily than as a grapheme. To my mind (and I’m yet to come across any research on this, so, again, pure conjecture) this is some kind of turning point, and we’re doing kids a disservice by holding them to the drills… except for spelling (in which case, we’re likely better spending more time eliciting graphemes through recall, than drilling them through recognition… but again… nuance… they may not be able to spell it reliably, yet).
So, that’s a couple of indicators I use for ‘escape velocity’. But how to let them escape, in a system that has mandates and fidelity placed higher than teacher training, is something I can’t comment on, except that the broad notion of ‘streaming’ (a la the Hansberrys) has to be involved somehow.
Now, your turn…
[Do jump over to the substack post to check the comments]
